Covenn vs contingency-fee audit firms
Profit-recovery audit firms that review supplier contracts for late-delivery, short-shipment and price-overcharge credits aren't new — they've existed for decades, and they work. The usual commercial model is contingency: no recovery, no fee, but when they do find something, the fee is typically 20-30% of whatever gets recovered.
Covenn does the same underlying job — matching contract terms against your purchase orders, goods-receipt records and invoices to find credits you're owed — but as software you run yourself for a flat monthly subscription, not a firm that takes a cut.
The actual cost difference
Say an audit finds £3,000 in recoverable credits in a given month. At a 25% contingency fee (the middle of the typical 20-30% range), a firm keeps £750 of that, leaving you £2,250. Covenn Professional is £499/month flat regardless of what's found, leaving you £2,501 — and every pound recovered above that £3,000 is entirely yours, not split further.
The breakeven point against a 25% fee is simple arithmetic: Professional (£499/month) pays for itself once monthly recoveries pass roughly £2,000; Starter (£199/month) pays for itself past roughly £800. Below those levels, the maths can go either way depending on exactly what's found — this isn't a claim that Covenn is always cheaper, just the actual breakeven logic so you can work it out for your own numbers.
Where the two approaches genuinely differ
- Who does the work. A contingency firm's service typically includes finding and pursuing claims on your behalf. Covenn finds the credit and drafts the claim letter, but you review, edit and send it yourself — nothing is ever sent to a supplier automatically.
- Control over the relationship. A third-party firm pursuing a supplier on your behalf has no stake in that relationship continuing — you do. Because you're the one sending it, you control how: draft a formal claim, or a softer version that flags the finding for the record and defers it to your next renewal conversation instead of raising it mid-contract.
- Upfront commitment. A contingency firm has no cost if nothing is found. A Covenn subscription is a real recurring cost regardless of outcome — free tier aside, you're paying whether or not a given month turns up much.
- Speed and control. Covenn's matching is automatic and immediate once your data is imported — no waiting on an external firm's review cycle, and you can re-run an audit any time you import new data.
- Ongoing monitoring. A contingency engagement is typically a one-off review. A subscription is built for checking continuously as new purchase orders and invoices come in, not a single historical sweep.
Which actually fits better
If you have no internal capacity to import and review data yourself, and would rather hand the whole thing to a firm with no upfront cost, a contingency-fee audit is a reasonable choice — that's exactly the gap they fill. If you'd rather run the check yourself, see every figure's evidence directly, and keep control over whether and how a claim actually goes to a supplier, a flat-fee subscription is the better fit.
Check what one order could be worth, free →
Sign up to run a full supplier audit →
See also Covenn vs manual spreadsheet tracking if you're weighing this against doing it in-house by hand instead.